Convert to block theme or start from scratch?

Deciding whether to convert your existing WordPress site to a block theme or to start from scratch can be challenging. Here are some considerations to help you decide:

1. Current Site Complexity

  • Convert: If your site has custom functionality or a complex structure, converting may be less disruptive.
  • Start from Scratch: If your site is simple or you are planning a major redesign, starting fresh might be easier and cleaner.

2. Time and Resources

  • Convert: Typically requires less time and resources as you build upon your existing site.
  • Start from Scratch: This can be more time-consuming but offers an opportunity to rethink and optimize your site’s structure and design.

3. Technical Debt

  • Convert: May carry over legacy issues and technical debt.
  • Start from Scratch: Allows you to avoid inheriting old problems, leading to a more maintainable codebase.

4. Learning Curve

  • Convert: Less steep, especially if you’re already familiar with the Classic Editor and current theme setup.
  • Start from Scratch: Steeper learning curve but can be beneficial long-term as you become proficient with the new block-based approach.

5. Future-Proofing

  • Convert: Can be a stopgap measure, providing a smoother transition while gradually adopting new features.
  • Start from Scratch: More future-proof as it leverages the latest WordPress capabilities fully from the beginning.

Steps for Converting to a Block Theme:

  1. Backup Your Site: Ensure you have a complete backup before making any changes.
  2. Choose a Block Theme: Select a theme that supports the block editor.
  3. Update Content: Open pages in the Classic Editor and convert them to blocks.
  4. Customize: Adjust and customize your new block theme as needed.

Steps for Starting from Scratch:

  1. Plan Your Site: Define your site’s structure, design, and functionality.
  2. Select a Block Theme: Choose a theme that fully supports the block editor.
  3. Develop and Customize: Build your site using the block editor, taking advantage of new features and block patterns.
  4. Migrate Content: Move content from your old site to the new one, ensuring everything fits the new design.

Choosing between converting and starting from scratch depends on your specific needs, goals, and resources. Both approaches have their advantages and can be tailored to fit your project requirements.

Leave a Reply